Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
AI Is a False God (thewalrus.ca)
15 points by jasonpeacock on May 30, 2024 | hide | past | favorite | 15 comments


ohh dear flying spaghetti monster, that was a lot of words about nothing. And the first comment is about religion. I don't want to live on this planet anymore.


> was a lot of words about nothing

It's worth remembering that just because you can't make sense of something, it doesn't mean there isn't sense to be had. Software engineers seem particularly prone to forget about that.


Wow this article manages to quote a philosopher's book about AI from 2014. Way back before any hint that LLMs and scale would rush the stage. If someone finds some substantial information in the article, please tell me, I gave up.


I think it's important to put "AI" into some perspective. Despite it's apparent wonder and power it is little more than a advanced lossy compression algorithm (latent-space with back propagation most times) and a natural language query interface. SQL with a facelift.

Once you see the man behind the curtain it loses most of it's shine.


[flagged]


> A human made god is always a false god.

This is probably the best argument for atheism I've ever heard.


There was this sci-fi novel I read some decades ago about a supercomputer that knew everything and could answer any question, so one day it was asked something like "what has been the biggest invention ever by man?". The supercomputer whirs for a while, then replies "God". I can't recall what novel was, I read it probably 35-40 years ago, but I believe it was much older.


The idea is to search for the truth and discard beliefs you understand to be false and not get stuck on them. If you know it is created by man, such as AI, you can know it's not God. Faith is mystery, it's not science.

Atheists are the strongest believers of all, because they are 100% sure that they know exactly what any other person means when using the word "God" and that it's the same idea that they have themselves discarded.


Such a young religion... I am more for the real stuff, like Zarathustra or even older :)


The Bible is a collection of most all older myths and beliefs from the region. Think of it like blues music, everything building on what was before.


The bible also encourages genocide, rape, slavery, misogyny and capital punishment.

Perhaps it's wise not to listen.


I normally don't comment on stuff like this, but this is dishonest at best.

The bible is a collection of multiple books, some are stories and myths, some are historical, some are divine law / ways to live. The vast majority of faith traditions today that root the bible as divine revelation do not see the old testament's law as binding on modern man, but rather either instruction for a more "devolved" people, part of an invalidated covenant, or part of an older "aeon" or age of man.


When you are free to ignore certain parts the whole thing becomes less and less believable


When you are free to ignore certain parts you open your mind to a world of knowledge and ideas, from every source imaginable.


What I said is accurate. I'm aware of what the bible is comprised of.

Your response is the usual "oh those bits are just old and silly".

To say that my comment is "dishonest at best" relies on cherry-picking the parts that are palatable in modern society, as you've pointed out.


[flagged]


Quite an aggressive response.

I don't expect anything of the bible... it's just a silly old book that I never think about.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: